Tuesday, October 09, 2007

Another Stereotypical TV Transsistah

5 October 2007

In a 2007-2008 TV season which continues last year's trend of having transgender characters, in 2007-08 we have the novel concept of a transwoman playing a transwoman.

Unfortunately we transsistahs are still getting the short end of the stick.

While many people in the transgender community are excited about Candis Cayne playing Carmelita on ABC's Dirty Sexy Money, and are looking forward to the continued Season 2 exploits of Rebecca Romijn's character Alexis Meade on Ugly Betty, there was another transgender character that debuted this week as well.

On the ABC show Big Shots, it intrduces us in the debut episode to a character played by a transsistah named Jazzmun.

But before we hail that as progress, Jazzmun is playing Dontrelle, a transsexual hooker.

It figures that we transsistahs once again get stuck being painted by the hooker brush while white transwomen are seen running a magazine or being the love interest of a US senator.

As the late Esther Rolle said in her Good Times role as Florida Evans, "Damn, Damn, Damn!"

Memo to Hollywood: Is it so hard for you to create an African-American transgender character that fits the reality of the 90% of us who don't partake of sex work to make our living? Is it that difficult for you to craft an African-American transgender character that isn't the punchline of a joke or doesn't end up dead in the first five minutes of the show?

If it is, may I suggest calling Sheryl Lee Ralph, who played a transsistah named Claire on Showtime's short lived Barbershop: The Series. I think she'd be happy to give y'all some pointers on creating a non-stereotypical transwoman of African descent. If she's not available, dial up Norman Lear, who in addition to creating All In The Family's Beverly LaSalle, created Edith Stokes, the first realistic transsistah character for The Jefferson's back in 1977.

If they aren't available, just e-mail me and I'll be happy to do it if the price is right.

I'm sick of seeing transsistahs being portrayed as hookers or murder victims. We have enough problems in the African-American community trying to dispel that negative image. Just when we're starting to make a little progress, here comes a TV show that reinforces the negativity that we've worked so hard to counteract.

I'm looking forward to the day when I see an African-American transgender character on TV again that reflects my values and the way that I live my life.

I guess if I want to see that type of positive transsistah character, I'm gonna have to dust off that script I was working on and do it my damned self. . . .

ALMOST MYSELF

DVD
Reflections on Mending & Transcending Gender

BY Tom Murry

(DVD Format 82 min.) TJoe Murray Videos 2007
The DVD contains the 82 minute documentary
ALMOST MYSELF with BONUS material.
BONUS material includes:
Additional Director comments
Scenes from 2005's West Hollywood
Day of Remembrance & Rally
Previews
"Road to Trinidad" Music Video

"One could say that this is as much a film about society and the way people who are considered
“different” are treated, as much as a film about the transgender people I met." - Tom Murray

Almost Myself - Reflections on Mending and Transcending Gender. After finding a most unusual web site that was seeking funds to help reverse a sex change, award winning filmmaker Tom Murray set out on a fascinating cross country journey to explore just a small part of the vastly diverse transgender community. The filmmaker in trying to define the film and what he learned in making it said that it could be described as Transgender 101 by and for a Non-transgender person What happens with a young Gay man, struggling not only with his sexuality but also gender, decides to have surgery to become a female, and later in life decides to return to being a Gay man again? Can someone live their life full time as a female, but still have a penis? What s life like for a former male college football player, finally living her life as the women she was always meant to be? These are just some of the stories told in the fascinating, poignant, informative and some may say controversial documentary ALMOST MYSELF. The film focuses primarily on women who are white and older, yet were identified as male at birth. The stories include journeys of boyhood to womanhood and the struggles of mending and transcending gender. . . .

Film Series at Ithaca College to Screen Documentary on Sex Change Reversal

ITHACA, NY—The Out of the Closet and Onto the Screen film series at Ithaca College will feature the documentary “Almost Myself: Reflections on Mending and Transcending Gender” on Monday, Oct. 15, at 7 p.m. in Textor 102. The screening is free and open to the public. The film tells the story of Judy Kirchner, a transgender woman who contemplates reversing her sex change as she approaches her 40th birthday.
After being born a male, having surgery and living nearly 20 years as a female, Kirchner had decided to become a guy again. Filmmaker Tom Murray, who was conducting research for a documentary on gay life in rural America, stumbled upon a website Kirchner had set up titled HelpMeReverseMySexChange.Org. “Almost Myself” is Murray’s story of how Kirchner unraveled her childhood medical history and fell into and out of the “clutches” of the ex-gay ministries, exploring just a small part of the vastly diverse transgender community.
Sponsored by the Center for Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual & Transgender (LGBT) Education, Outreach and Services, the film series focuses on the ways people transgress, challenge and redefine gender as we know it.
For more information on the series, contact Lisa Maurer, LGBT Center coordinator, at (607) 274-7394 or lmaurer@ithaca.edu.

India: Transgender to host TV show on Star Vijay

Monday - Oct 08, 2007

Meher Khanna - Televisionpoint.com | Chennai

A transgender will host a 30-minute-long, weekly chat show on the rights of sexual minorities on Star Vijay that will feature transgenders telling the story of their lives.

Rose, a smart and chic transgender postgraduate in bio medical sciences, will be the anchor. The show, which is in the pre-production stage, will contain ingredients of drama, emotion and laughter and, in the bargain, serve a social cause as well.

"Previously, we produced a game show in which HIV positive women came out with their life stories driving a message to the audience not to discriminate against them. Vijay TV has always tried to knit entertainment with a social message. This is a part of that effort," sources in the channel said.

The programme will throw light on who the transgenders are and the medical reasons behind the transformation of a person born as a man into a woman. Apart from this, the show will have transgenders speaking about their experience of growing up and humiliation by family and the society.

Psychiatrists will be present in the show to explain queries on sexual orientation and gender disparity. The show would also have a transgender and her family narrating their story of denial and acceptance appealing to the public to accept their children who are born transgenders and not reject them.

Rose said the programme would certainly bring a change in the way people perceive her ilk because of the mass appeal of television.

"It has been my long standing dream to be a television and a movie star to prove to this world what a transgender is capable of. I never spoke about my gender at home until I completed higher education. After completing studies I had to tell my parents. After many struggles they have now accepted me," said Rose, who was called Ramesh at home.

Rose runs a website design portal and nurtures a dream to act in movies, achieve what sizzling transgender Hollywood actor Candis Cayne did to her community - fight the stigma against sexual minorities through the media and encourage other transgenders to live their identity.

Gay And Lesbian Medical Association Urges Inclusion Of Transgender People In Federal Workplace Discrimination Bill

The Gay and Lesbian Medical Association (GLMA) announced its support for including transgender people in the federal Employment Non-Discrimination Act (ENDA). The legislation as originally written would ban workplace discrimination based on sexual orientation, perceived sexual orientation, and gender identity or expression. Last week, however, congressional leaders put forward a revised version which omitted protections based on gender identity and expression, stating that this was necessary to obtain sufficient votes for passage.

Rebecca Allison, a transgender cardiologist practicing in Phoenix, Arizona and GLMA's President Elect, understands the impact of workplace discrimination. "I personally know transgender physicians who were forced to abandon successful practices after announcing their intention to transition," she said. "In addition to causing financial losses, discrimination in the workplace can reduce productivity and put victims at risk for depression. Including transgender people in ENDA will help prevent some of these harms."

"We must do everything we can to oppose the marginalization of transgender people," said GLMA Executive Director Joel Ginsberg. "Transgender people are just as deserving of employment protections as anyone else. We are urging our members and all healthcare providers committed to equality for LGBT people to contact their representatives to insist that gender identity and expression be reincorporated into this critical legislation."

The mission of the Gay and Lesbian Medical Association is to ensure equality in healthcare for lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgender individuals and healthcare professionals. More information is available at http://www.glma.org.

The Inner Battle of the Sexes

Kayla Lynch

8 October 2007

In our society, there are two clear genders: male and female. Androgyny may be trendy, but there are only 'male' and 'female' check boxes on driver's license forms, birth certificates, and other forms. So what happens if you just don't fit into either category? What happens when the doctor picks you up at birth, slaps you on the backside, and pronounces you a bouncing baby girl…but you don't feel like one? How are you going to live, growing up your whole life waiting for your male sex organs to grow like all the other boys, but they never do?

Gender identity is how you see yourself. You might have been born a man or woman and "just know" that you are male or female. But when you don't fit into a specific category of gender, you're put under the umbrella term of transgender. The term 'transgender' is broad and covers many aspects of the gender experience. Typically, transgender people have come to the conclusion that they are trapped in the wrong body. Some will go through hormone therapy, electrolysis, plastic surgery, or sex reassignment surgery to complete their transition to the correct body. Being transgender is different from cross-dressing because cross-dressers don't necessarily want to be the opposite sex. The terms 'transgender' and 'transsexual' are slightly different as well: while a transgender person typically will not have the sex reassignment surgery, a transsexual person will.

FTMs (female-to-male) and MTFs (male-to-female) have a difficult time dealing with their gender dysphoria within modern society. They may be labeled homosexual even when they are not so inclined. Some transgender showgirls have exploited their physiology, particularly in the pornography industry, and coined the term 'she-male,' which can be highly offensive to MTFs.

While some trans-people have a clear perception of themselves as being either male or female, some do not share this view. Some feel: Bi-gendered: They have a male and female side to their personalities. . . .

Monday, October 08, 2007

"Doctor Who" Spoof. . .David Tennant in drag

Heterosexual cross-dressing less understood than being gay

Dear Straight Talk: I am 19 and I have a secret. I am a cross-dresser. I've been wearing female clothes and makeup since I was 11. Honestly, life would be easier if I was gay. When you are gay, people understand you, you fit in. But nobody understands cross-dressing.

I'm a good-looking, completely heterosexual male with desires to marry and have a family someday. Cross-dressing is my passion; I enjoy it and it's completely harmless.

Last year, I worked and traveled in Europe and I was able to explore my passion a lot, but being home again is depressing.

I want to tell my girlfriend, but my last girlfriend left me over it and I'm sure my family will think I'm a pervert. Some days I wonder if I even belong in this world. - Steve and "Stephanie."

From Rose, 19: You do belong. Who is to say which clothes are meant for females and which are meant for males? I wear pants all the time, so why can't you wear a dress? Your girlfriend needs to know the real you. How else can she love and accept you? Depending on your parents, some things are best left unsaid. About suicide: I've been there and it's not worth it. Life is a beautiful thing; sometimes you just have to look for it. And sometimes you just have to breathe.

From Sawyer, 16: You picked a tough passion. Last year I dressed as a girl for the Halloween dance. I looked so "hot," my girlfriend shunned me all evening. I thought it would be fun but it threw everybody off.

From Peter, 20: People fear what they don't understand. Start by showing your family videos of Eddie Izzard, a famous cross-dresser comedian. It might help if they can appreciate a man because he is funny, not because he's wearing women's clothing. . . .

What language barrier?


It is a truism that men and women do not communicate in the same way. But is there really any evidence to support this Mars-and-Venus theory? Oxford language professor Deborah Cameron investigates in the first of three extracts from her new book

Click here for the table on Gender differences in verbal/communicative behaviour adapted from Hyde, 'The Gender Similarities Hypothesis'.


Monday October 1, 2007
The Guardian


Do men and women speak the same language? Can they ever really communicate? These questions are not new, but since the early 1990s there has been a new surge of interest in them. Countless self-help and popular psychology books have been written portraying men and women as alien beings, and conversation between them as a catalogue of misunderstandings. The most successful exponents of this formula, such as Deborah Tannen, author of You Just Don't Understand, and John Gray, author of Men Are From Mars, Women Are From Venus, have topped the bestseller lists on both sides of the Atlantic. Advice on how to bridge the communication gulf between the sexes has grown into a flourishing multimedia industry. Gray's official website, for instance, promotes not only his various Mars and Venus books, but also seminars, residential retreats, a telephone helpline and a dating service. . . .

Dude looks (and acts) like a lady

Kaley Relaz


10/3/07

What makes a man a man? What makes a woman a woman? Other than our obvious anatomical differences, it's really the gender role we take on that's the deciding factor.

Let's take a hermaphrodite: The way that person dresses, interacts with others, walks, talks, etc. are the traits others will use to assume that person's sex. But for the majority - who we'll assume aren't hermaphrodites - we still display behaviors/characteristics others use to decide whether we are manly men, womanly women or vice versa. Whatever the case may be, every woman and man acquires and displays both a masculine and feminine side.

But which sex has more influence on the other? On the surface, men seem to be the answer because society is primarily influenced by institutions that have been generally male-dominated.

It's perfectly normal for a girl to wear blue but still debatable for a guy to wear pink. A girl may gain respect if she downs a beer-bong in seconds, but a guy will probably lose respect if he orders a cosmopolitan.

A girl may be considered the "dream girl" if she loves watching football, playing golf and having "Boondock Saints" on her list of favorite movies. A guy, however, would most likely not be considered the "dream guy" if he loves gymnastics, getting pedicures and has "The Notebook" on his movies list. I'm not at all implying these "manly" traits apply to all men and the "girly" traits apply to all women, but I assume most people will agree to those superficial generalizations.

Going on the idea of this "dream girl," I've noticed that she's becoming more prevalent because our society has been slowly but surely moving in a direction where women have more power and freedoms.

Let's take sexual freedom for example. I visited the University of Madison this past weekend and met a group of girls who play a game called Bango. Like Bingo, Bango requires a board with squares and the first person to achieve five squares in a row wins. But Bango squares have descriptions like "Facial Hair" or "Out-of-Towner." One must at least make out with a guy embodying that description to cross that square off. . . .

Actors and Actresses Swapping "Roles" Prove It's not Sex that Makes up Gender Identity

According to the Merriam-Webster Online Dictionary, gender is "the behavioral, cultural or psychological traits typically associated with one sex." Sometimes we associate gender with our sex, but we are mistaken, for sex is genetically determined. It is the inner XX or XY chromosomes that create our outer sex organs. In layman terms, gender is the role we play in society that best represents our personal preference in the way we identify with others.

In film, character roles are the first representations audiences have and their attire, voice, mannerisms and language make us assume a gender- even if a male is playing a female role or visa versa.

Since the beginning of the 20th century, men and women have switched assumed gender roles in film, creating characters from scratch and learning a new way to move, walk and talk.

Film has obviously evolved since the kinetograph created by William Dickson in 1889. The only time we view moving pictures from a machine that what an optometrist use sto check your eyesight, is when we are in a late 19th century themed amusement park or a film history museum. Along with that evolution came new ideas in both dramatic and comedic forms on how to sell box office tickets.

Gender swapping in film is not as uncommon as it seems. Normally it takes on a comedic performance so audiences don't thing twice about Martin Lawrence putting on a fat suit and becoming the female character, Big Momma.

Along with Law-rence, many of our most famous actors and actresses have acted as an opposite gender role than they are used to playing. Most times, men play men and women play women. But there is that rare actor or actress who can pull off a man or woman playing the opposite sex or an overly feminine or masculine character rendering an amusing, almost parodic of quality.

In the past few years, men and women have been praised for their gender-bending performances. Charlize Theron won the Academy Award for Best Leading Actress for her portrayal of the tough, promiscuous, gay character Aileen in Monster. Felicity Huffman was nominated for her role as a transsexual named Sabrina "Bree" Osbourne in 2006's Transamerica, and Philip Seymour Hoffman won Best Leading Actor as the notoriously feminine Truman Capote. . . .

POV, Critique, Opinion: How did the T get in LGBT?

The 30-year fight for a federal gay civil rights law may fail because activists insist on including rights for transgendered people too. Has gay inclusiveness gone too far too fast?

By John Aravosis

Like an ever-expanding mushroom cloud of diversity, every few years America's gay leaders and activists welcome a new category of member to the community. Wikipedia walks us through our complicated family history:

"LGBT [lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgendered] or GLBT are the most common terms [to describe the gay community] ... When not inclusive of transgender people it is shortened to LGB. It may also include two additional Qs for queer and questioning (sometimes abbreviated with a question mark) (LGBTQ, LGBTQQ, GLBTQ2); a variant being LGBU, where U stands for "unsure", an I for intersex (LGBTI), another T for transsexual (LGBTT), another T (or TS or the numeral 2) for two-spirited people, and an A for straight allies or asexual (LGBTA). At its fullest, then, it is some permutation of LGBTTTIQQA."

In simpler times we were all gay. But then the word "gay" started to mean "gay men" more than women, so we switched to the more inclusive "gay and lesbian." Bisexuals, who were only part-time gays, insisted that we add them too, so we did (not without some protest), and by the early 1990s we were the lesbian, gay and bisexual, or LGB community. Sometime in the late '90s, a few gay rights groups and activists started using a new acronym, LGBT -- adding T for transgender/transsexual. And that's when today's trouble started. . . .

Transgender: Iran's sex-change operations

In a country that has outlawed homosexuality, Frances Harrison meets one Iranian cleric who says the right to a sex change is a human right.

For 20 years Mahyar has been a woman trapped in a man's body.

As a small child Mahyar liked dressing up in women's clothes and experimenting with make-up but as she grew older it got more difficult. "I badly needed to do it but it had to be in secret," she says.

Now she wants to have a sex-change operation - if she can muster the �00 it will cost in Iran. If her family doesn't help financially, she says she might sell one of her kidneys to pay for it.

"People say you'll get other illnesses but I think I can live without one kidney. I cannot live between the sky and the earth," says Mahyar.

Locked-up

Surgeons have already removed Mahyar's testicles. After the operation, her older brother locked her up for a week and wouldn't let her use the telephone. Mahyar's brother says someone has put a spell on her.

When Mahyar wants to feel normal she goes to the clinic of Dr Mirjalali - Iran's leading sex-change surgeon. There are women who were men, men who were women and those like Mahyar waiting for the operation they believe will be a sort of rebirth.

Dr Mirjalali says in Europe a surgeon would do about 40 sex change operations in a decade. He's done 320 in the last 12 years in Iran.

"If you saw them out in the street you wouldn't realise that one day they were the opposite sex," he boasts.

The doctor will use parts of Mahyar's intestines to create female sex organs. He warns it involves five or six hours of difficult surgery and weeks of painful recuperation.

Mahyar loves to go to cosmetics shops - and try out new nail varnish for her long manicured nails and discuss with the amused female shop assistants the best sort of foundation cream to hide her stubbly chin.

The sight of a man wearing make-up does turn heads on the street. Islamic tradition does not allow cross dressing - a man should only dress in male clothes. But that is not to say Iran's religious scholars are antagonistic to transsexuals.

Hojatulislam Kariminia wrote his doctoral thesis on the implications of sex-change operations for Islamic law.

He is a leading expert on questions like does a husband or wife need the permission of their spouse before a sex change operation? Is their marriage automatically annulled afterwards and what happens to the wife's dowry money or inheritance if she becomes a man.

Ayatollah Khomeini

He shows me the book in Arabic in which, 41 years ago, Ayatollah Khomeini wrote about new medical issues like transsexuality.

"I believe he was the first Islamic scientist in the world of Islam who raised the issue of sex change," says Hojatulislam Kariminia.

The Ayatollah's ruling that sex-change operations were allowed has been reconfirmed by Iran's current spiritual leader. . . .

Sunday, October 07, 2007

Danna and Candis audition. . .performing gender

View video here.

The ENDA situation: How you can help.

October 6, 2007

ENDA is the name given to a bill prohibiting employment discrimination on the basis of actual or perceived sexual orientation. The bill is currently in the House, and while it originally included protections for transgendered people, on September 27, it was announced that the bill would be stripped of these protections in order to get the bill passed (you can read the original bill here.)

This is not the first time this legislation has been proposed, nor is it the first time that the Human Rights Campaign (HRC) has supported an exclusive bill. If you feel, as I do, that transgender protections should be included in this bill, please read on.

From Phyllis Randolph Frye, a.k.a. THE PHYLLABUSTER, at prfrye@aol.com:

HRC sent its press release out today. Essentially, it boasts of being inclusive of GLBT since 2004 and wanting an inclusive ENDA (HR 2015). BUT IT WILL NOT URGE ANY MEMBER OF CONGRESS TO OPPOSE THE BARNEY FRANK NON-INCLUSIVE ENDA SUBSTITUTE (HR 3685).

Okay, GLBT and supportive straight friends -- so what do we do?

1. Go here to learn how the Barney Frank non-inclusive ENDA substitute bill (HR 3685) also waters down the rights of regular gays and lesbians. (Way to go, Barn!)

2. Personally contact your Member of Congress and say you want the original inclusive ENDA (HR 2015) passed. Tell them that ole Barn does NOT represent mainstream GLBT folks!

3. If you have given money to HRC since 2004, tell HRC (www.hrc.org) that "they lied" and you demand a full refund.

4. Look at this list.

a. Send your money to these groups instead.

b. If you want your group on this list, contact lmottet@thetaskforce.org.

5. If you live in Nancy Pelosi's district or Barney Frank's district, let them know about it.

6. If you live in Tammie Baldwin's district, thank her for remaining LGBT inclusive.

7. If you live in the DC area, protest this Saturday's (October 6) HRC National Dinner. For details contact, Ethan St. Pierre at RadicalGuy@Gmail.com.

8. Go to the HRC website and type in your city to learn where your local HRC group contact is.

a. Bend their ear on this issue.

b. Learn when their HRC fundraiser is, and start preparing the protest.

9. Fro the best up-to-dates, go to either the NGLTF site or the National Center for Transgender Equality site.

10. Keep your eye on the prize and get all of your friends to do #2 above.

And from the National Center for Transgender Equality:
Daily Update on ENDA
from Mara Keisling, NCTE Executive Director
Thursday, October 4

Today I spent quite a bit of time explaining (re-explaining) to the media and others that the current ENDA situation is not one of pragmatic people versus crazy idealists (not that there is anything wrong with being either practical or idealistic). No one is demanding that transgender people get ours or no one gets anything. The greatest likelihood in fact is that this year will end with no ENDA protections becoming law to protect anyone. We will all need to work together to pass the bill in the House, even harder in the Senate and then somehow overcome a likely veto by the White House.

Additionally, gender identity is not synonymous with transgender and sexual orientation is not synonymous with gay and bi people. Just as trans people face discrimination based on sexual orientation, gay people face gender identity discrimination. Yesterday, five legal organizations (Lambda Legal, National Center for Lesbian Rights, The Transgender Law Center, GLAD, and the ACLU) issued a joint statement (www.lambdalegal.org) that explained this and other legal shortcomings of a sexual orientation-only ENDA.

A split ENDA hurts all LGBT people-whether you are pragmatic, idealistic or, like most of us, both.

Today (Thursday) was another very fast paced day in Washington and around the country. Congressional offices are definitely hearing from everyone and it is just as definite that everyone's great work is really impacting things. Members of Congress and their staffs are telling us that they are getting calls and visits from people like you-people who live in their districts.

The number of organizations who have publicly proclaimed their support for transgender people and our desire to pass the fully inclusive Employment Non-Discrimination Act (H.R. 2015) was up at about 180 the last time I checked sometime this afternoon. Earlier today, we blew past 2,500 signatures on the petitions that we co-produced with the Transgender Law Center. People are really enthused and turning that enthusiasm into action. And it's working.

One side effect of all of this sudden somewhat unexpected activity is that our expenses have gone up tremendously. Suddenly we are paying for meals for volunteers, lots of taxis to Capitol Hill, consultants, cell phone minutes. This coming week, it looks like there will be some travel costs and hotel rooms for specific people who we need to have here in DC. All in all, we think that this may cost us an additional $10,000-15,000-all of which is very difficult for a small organization like NCTE. Though so many people are doing so much, your financial support would also be very helpful. One donor sent us $150-one dollar in honor of each of the LGBT organizations who has stepped up in solidarity to support transgender people and our effort of keep ENDA inclusive of all LGBT people. If you would like to make a donation, please go to our website. It would help a lot.

Thank you.

~Mara

Mara Keisling
Executive Director
National Center for Transgender Equality


The National Center for Transgender Equality is a national social justice organization devoted to ending discrimination and violence against transgender people through education and advocacy on national issues of importance to transgender people. The National Center for Transgender Equality is a 501(c)3 organization. For more information, please visit our website.

We need your support to continue this work. Click here to join our mailing list or to donate now. Thank you! . . .

The Great American Public On Transgender: Just the Numbers

Saturday, October 6, 2007


Did you know that the first trans-inclusive legislation goes back to 1975? I didn't. Did you know that 32 years later it is deja vu all over again, vis-a-vis debating what to include and how?


From the HRC's last workplace studies release (page 13), the rise in companies recognizing gender identity and gender expression:

Free Image Hosting at allyoucanupload.com


Does that growth rate look like "11 years" of toil? Here's another, showing the trend:

Until 1999, there were few transgender H.R. policies at employers, and none at large employers. However, policy adoption began to rise in 1997 and began a rapid rise in 2001. ... [in 2004] 200 companies ... 50 companies of the Fortune 500.





Cheryl Jacques in 2004:

In fact, recent polling shows 61 percent of registered voters and 85 percent of registered GLBT voters support workplace protections for transgender people.


... starts to look like that other white elephant walking around Congress, DADT.



The NGLTF 104 pages on transgender history and equality measures before the law. Did you know that the first trans-inclusive legislation goes back to 1975? I didn't. Did you know that 32 years later it is deja vu all over again, vis-a-vis debating what to include and how?


It's not too late to send a Congressman to boot camp:


From Cornell's highly respected ILR School:

Sexual Orientation and Gender Identity
DV214 $ 695.00
Scheduled dates: [next is November 29th in New York]

In many workplaces, diversity training and education either ignores the issues of sexual orientation and gender identity or addresses these issues in a superficial way. This workshop is designed to prepare organizations, trainers, and other interested parties with a step-by-step guide for effectively addressing sexual orientation and gender identity in the workplace.



From the APA.


Symbolic legislation? Here is the current map of non-discrimination statues from NGLTF.

That doesn't include local ordinances, but that map is hardly a boat full of fish. True, there are ways around many (if not most) employment laws; but for every clever one there is probably at least one dumb one.



The rest of the English speaking world.

Britain dealt with gender-identity in what looks like a fairly comprehensive way in 2004. Yes. 3 years ago. (Go to "Schedule 6" at the very end of the document).

Our friends to the North appear to be less comprehensive, but moving forward just fine:

Gender identity is another story. The North West Territories is the only jurisdiction in Canada that lists gender identity specifically as a protected ground in its human rights legislation. Manitoba is a close second with its reference to protecting "gender-determined characteristics." Alberta references gender. But, that's it. In other provinces, human rights legislation has generally been interpreted to include gender identity under the protected characteristic "sex". Beyond that, there are only a handful of legal decisions in Canada that address discrimination in employment on the basis of gender identity. Now, that does not mean that Commissions haven't been talking about gender identity and trying to raise awareness about discrimination and harassment faced by transsexuals and transgendered persons. For example, click here to read the Ontario Human Rights Commission's Policy on Discrimination and Harassment because of Gender Identity.


[more on the international as it becomes available]

Barney Frank, Gay Rights Group Spar Over Employment Non-Discrimination Act

10/05/2007

By Bryan Ochalla

When Rep. Barney Frank (D-MA) unveiled a revised version of the proposed Employment Non-Discrimination Act (EDNA) last week that only would protect sexual orientation—a separate bill would prohibit discrimination based on gender identity—LGBT rights groups across the country displayed their displeasure by sending a letter to Congress that urged lawmakers to reject the “substitute legislation.”

The altered legislation also prompted a press release from Lambda Legal Executive Director Kevin Cathcart claiming the legislation had been “modified in several additional and troubling ways."

“In addition to the missing vital protections for transgender people on the job, this new bill also leaves out a key element to protect any employee, including lesbians and gay men who may not conform to their employer's idea of how a man or woman should look and act,” Cathcart said in the release. “This is a huge loophole through which employers sued for sexual orientation discrimination can claim that their conduct was actually based on gender expression, a type of discrimination that the new bill does not prohibit.”

On Wednesday, Rep. Frank responded with a press release of his own, in which he stated, “Lambda Legal’s analysis of the bill I have reintroduced to outlaw sexual orientation discrimination contains one essential error, and two misunderstandings of where we are in the legislative process.”

The “essential error,” according to Rep. Frank, involved Cathcart’s comment that the wording of the bill had been altered beyond the removal of the transgender protections.

"The second bill does omit reference to people who are transgender, but it makes no other change in the wording on this point," he said. "It neither adds nor deletes any reference to employers’ rights to fire people based on how they appear."

“The sexual orientation language in H.R. 3685 is the same language that has been in every version of ENDA since its first introduction in 1994,” Rep. Frank added. “There is nothing in case law or in ENDA’s history to indicate that absent gender identity coverage, the bill would inadequately protect gay, lesbian and bisexual people from discrimination.”

Rep. Frank’s main issue with the Lambda Legal release was that it asserted the new version of the bill would allow gay men and lesbians to be fired because they are too effeminate or masculine.

Such a statement “is an invitation to bigots to try to get around the law,” he said. “Fortunately, as Felix Frankfurter once said, the Constitution outlaws sophisticated as well as simple-minded forms of discrimination, and so do statutes specifically banning sexual orientation. Lambda Legal itself would easily defeat such an attempted end-run around the sexual orientation language.”

Lambda Legal made a supposed similar error regarding the religious exemption appearing in current and past versions of ENDA, according to the Congressman, according to Frank. “The fairly broad religious exemption that is in the new bill I recently introduced is essentially the same broad exemption that we had to give religious groups in previous years."

“We did make an effort to narrow it in the first ENDA bill this year, and a very good job of rewriting this was done with my strong support,” he added. “But once again we found that this would simply engender a degree of opposition from religious groups that would keep the bill from going forward.”

In a letter sent to Rep. Frank yesterday, Lambda Legal reiterated it’s stance on the revised bill, which was supposed to come before the U.S. House of Representatives on Tuesday but has since been postponed.

Removing gender identity "diminished the bill not only by excluding transgender people—a consequence we oppose in itself,” the organization stated in the letter. “The cut also made the bill far weaker by denying protection of the earlier version to those who may not identify as transgender but who are discriminated against because they are perceived as gender nonconforming. Lesbians, gay men and bisexuals frequently are perceived that way." . . .

Controversy dogs sexuality researcher

. . .Transgender response. . .(to a controversy. R.A.)

Susan Stryker, a queer historian, filmmaker, and author, told the B.A.R. that she considers Dreger a friend and reviewed the unpublished manuscript of the article. Stryker said she advised Dreger to "significantly revise and to think" about the article because she disagreed with Dreger's "interpretation of the controversy." She believes that Dreger is taking some of the heat from Bailey with the article by asserting her academic position and not taking into account the validity of how transgender women feel about Bailey's book and research.

"[She] doesn't address what the people are actually angry about and a part of that anger comes from ... other people putting themselves in a situation to define and determine the truth or authenticity of a transgender person's life," said Stryker.

Stryker felt that Dreger had a "genuine desire" to "shed some light on this place where there's a lot of heat," but that it was "misguided and misframed" and in the end "what Alice does is reproduce the very things that people are angry about."

It doesn't help, as author Julia Serano and Stryker point out, that Bailey and Blanchard are on the editorial board of the Archives of Sexual Behavior, where the article is being published.

Stryker is currently writing a response to Dreger's article for the journal.

Bailey doesn't believe that his position on the editorial board matters, because he told the B.A.R. that he did not review the manuscript. Dreger agreed that Bailey's position on the editorial board didn't matter.

Stryker told the B.A.R. that the transgender women who are angry about the book are scientists who think that The Man Who Would Be Queen is "bad science." What's worse, according to Stryker, is that bad science is being promoted in a popular book as "science" about transsexual women. Therefore, it's Stryker's opinion that Bailey misused his position as a psychologist.

But to Bailey, Blanchard's theory "explained what I was seeing" and went against what he believes is "this false idea that all transsexuals are women trapped in men's bodies" and "leads us on the wrong path to understanding gender identity in non-transsexual people."

Furthermore, Bailey adds, "The scientific work is not mainly mine ... my book is about the science of transsexualism, it's not the science of transsexualism."

Stryker believes there is a power struggle happening now that transgender women are gaining the platform to speak for themselves.

"What I say about you is what matters, not what you say about you," said Stryker about Bailey's attitude. "Who's the boss here? I'm the boss. It's really that kind of struggle that is going on."

Bailey and Dreger insist that the book wasn't scientific and therefore transgender women's arguments against the book through what Dreger discovered about the controversy aren't valid. She said that everything in her article is backed up with evidence.

"Even if Bailey didn't do anything as far as scientific fraud," said Serano, "he still promoted a non-scientific book as science, a book full of antidotes as though it were actual rigorous science."

Not only that, Bailey saw an opportunity to make money, which Serano perceives as "essentially exploiting trans women for personal gain."

Bailey doesn't perceive the fact that he wanted to make money as a problem.

"I don't think that makes me unusual to like the idea of making money," said Bailey. "And at that time I was pretty broke, so it had a special appeal."

But Serano believes Bailey's financial goal from the book only made the controversy worse. "I think this got personal because Bailey really tried to publicize it and make money off of it," she said.

Bailey doesn't believe that his book is anti-transsexual. He told the B.A.R. that he strongly supports sex reassignment surgery, especially in circumstances where it will improve an individual's life. He also said that he has actually received encouragement from transsexuals who are afraid to stand up in support of him because they fear similar attacks being made against them by Conway, James, and McCloskey. . . .

A traveling forum for equality

Bryana White at a picnic in New Paltz, N.Y., with other activists.
Bryana White at a picnic in New Paltz, N.Y., with other activists.

WHO: Bryana White, 23, of Kingston, R.I.

WHERE: New York

WHEN: Two weeks in July

WHY: To participate in the Right to Marry Campaign, organized by Soulforce Q, the young-adult arm of Soulforce, a nonprofit group based in Lynchburg, Va., that promotes "freedom for lesbian, gay, bisexual, and transgender people from religious and political oppression through the practice of relentless nonviolent resistance."

WHY CARE: "Marriage equality is an issue I'm passionate about," said White, a New Bedford native and doctoral student in clinical psychology at the University of Rhode Island. "Being heterosexual, I feel like I take it for granted, but it's ludicrous that friends of mine can't marry. I do have many friends who are LGBTQ [lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender, queer], and this is one way I can help them. And as an African-American woman, I see a lot of similarities with the civil rights movement. I feel like my generation isn't really politically active. A lot of us think no one will take us seriously. But this is a forum where we can do something."

WHY SOULFORCE: White heard about Soulforce from a friend at Vassar College, where she earned her undergraduate degree. "They follow the practices of Gandhi and Martin Luther King. We would be talking to lawmakers and regular people. A lot of people who aren't for marriage equality don't really know what it is. So it's not open bigotry, but misunderstanding."

WHY NEW YORK: Governor Eliot Spitzer proposed legislation this year that would legally sanction same-sex marriage in the state, though the Senate has yet to vote on the bill. Soulforce organized four caravans totaling 32 young adults to crisscross the state visiting the home districts of state lawmakers. They first had several days of training in Albany. "We went over the literature on marriage equality, talked about lawmakers, the process, and how we personally felt," White said. "It was one of the most amazing experiences I've had, being with this big mix of people from all over the country. It was predominantly people who were LGBTQ and comfortable with themselves, and speak passionately and eloquently. I would just be angry. The leaders were amazing people, young adults who have given themselves to these rights not just for two weeks, but for years."

TOWN TO TOWN: White's group "traveled all over upstate New York in our little van. For the most part we stayed at churches that were LGBTQ-friendly, or homes. We brought sleeping bags; it felt a little bit like summer camp." The route took them to Syracuse, Binghamton, Catskill, New Paltz, Poughkeepsie, and Long Island before reconvening with all the campaigners in the Bronx. Before scheduled meetings, "we'd arrive a few hours before and change into our meeting clothes in a Starbucks or in the van. Sometimes we'd talk to a senator or representative, sometimes a staff person, or sometimes they refused. When that happened, we'd contact supportive community members and throw a picnic in a local park."

DOOR TO DOOR: Occasionally the group canvassed neighborhoods and businesses to discuss the difference between civil unions and marriage. White said they were generally well received. "Maybe it's our youthful naivete and that we were a group of fresh-faced, well-dressed young people. People are generally respectful, even when they're not for something." . . .

Money can’t buy brains in 2 new shows

TV’s powerful men, as they follow the siren songs of their hormones, are blithering idiots.

JeffSimon
Updated: 10/07/07 8:40 AM


Bless television. We learn so much from it. Because of cop shows, the most sheltered of suburbanites can casually refer to a “perp’s jacket” as it were a phrase that tumbled from their lips daily. The rest of us know exactly what’s meant, too — not a dandy new piece of fall wardrobe but the criminal record of some rotten scum just hauled in for questioning by Horatio Caine or Olivia Benson.

We know from all the “CSI” shows that you don’t need blood to check DNA, just a quick cheek swab will do. So we were all fully prepared when the Bike Path killer was caught by cops swooping down on the silverware he left after dinner at the Sole restaurant. (Imagine how that news story would have played if we had never seen “CSI.” Our jaws would still be on the floor.)

If it weren’t for the guys in the booth, most of America’s Sunday football fanatics couldn’t smugly lecture their wives, girlfriends and daughters on nickel and dime defenses and the vicissitudes of the West Coast offense.

And now, courtesy of TV’s new fall season, the phrase “trannie hooker” (transsexual prostitute for you Disney Channel partisans) is probably as commonplace a phrase over the breakfast table as “soccer practice,” “working late at the office” and “soy milk.”

No less than two — count ’em — trannie hookers figured prominently as pivotal plot moments in new fall series about the excessively rich. And both of them were used to prove that wealthy and powerful white guys are secretly kinky and hopeless doofuses besides.

One of them — ABC’s nicely unsavory and genuinely sophisticated “Dirty Sexy Money” — was played by an actual transsexual (Candis Cane, whose real first name was Brendan) who decided, as part of the show’s inaugural hype, to go on as many infotainment shows as possible and reveal what she looked like when she used to be a man.

As the world of “Access Hollywood Inside Entertainment Tonight” covered this “story,” we were all supposed to marvel at how this tall beautiful shapely woman was once a man even though her voice was about an octave lower than mine (and in my high school glee club, I was in the bass section).

To have virtually the identical semi-comic plot development in new TV shows in the same week was nothing if not bracing.

On “Dirty Sexy Money,” Billy Baldwin played a rich ambitious pol — a future senator from New York State — who was suddenly set upon by the transsexual girlfriend he vowed to break up with before his wife found out, only to spend the night with her at his favorite four-star trysting palace.

On “Big Shots,” Dylan McDermott is a tough guy executive with a perennial three-day beard who is now being blackmailed because he had a truckstop assignation with a youknow- what (this one, though, without the benefit of metamorphic surgery).

The point, in both shows, was essentially comic — that powerful men, as they follow the siren songs of their hormones, are blithering idiots.

The show’s themselves are night and day.

“Dirty Sexy Money” is exhilaratingly wicked because it has a veneer of genuine sophistication about the world of the super rich — where yacht-buying idiot sons have elementary hygiene problems and the nastiest S.O.B. in the entire mega-money family is the one who wears the clerical collar. (And there, I submit, is a genuinely new wrinkle in American TV, its first snobbish, mean-spirited, hypocritical, vicious clergyman. Somewhere in heaven, Nathaniel Hawthorne probably approves.)

“Big Shots” is a dumb, bad but marginally watchable fantasy about a group of very wealthy and powerful men who complain to each other at the country club that they’ve become “the new women.”

As much as “Dirty Sexy Money” actually seems to have a genuine feel for the alarms and diversions of those who, as the proverbial old saying goes, have “more money than God,” “Big Shots” seems to be making it up as it goes along, just to show you Joshua Malina as a crisis manager with a gymnastic girlfriend on the side, Christopher Titus as a whipped multimillionaire (to please his wife last week, he got a Brazilian wax) and McDermott whose cynical, free-spirited long lost daughter has come back into his life at the exact same time as his blackmailing truck stop assignation.

The cast deserves a muchbetter show, but if its writers can just keep on watching “Dirty Sexy Money,” they might actually get a few decent ideas to make their show cannier.

About “Cane,” CBS’ most hyped of all the “Rich Are Different From You and Me” shows, the less said the better. It’s a preposterous cyclamate melodrama about the sugar business, an English language telenovela that wants to marry “The Godfather” and “Dynasty” and winds up, instead, humiliating Jimmy Smits and Hector Elizondo worse than any kinky assignation.

What a thing to do to Smits who, when last seen on prime time, was the president of us all. . . .