Friday, October 05, 2007
Understanding transgender populations – A personal story
Leslie Webb, director of the diversity education center at Central Washington University, shares her story:
Chris walked into my office yesterday afternoon to talk with me about the upcoming visit he had planned for the weekend. He was heading over the mountains to talk with his mother about identifying as transgender and discuss the fact that he is about to start the outward transitioning process. The trepidation he was experiencing was due to a number of different factors, and coming out to his family—both sides—was not going to be easy.
Chris and I have known each other for several years and have connected repeatedly about gender identity and gender expression. Chris has been dealing with gender identity for a long time and has begun a full fledged coming out process. He recently self-disclosed to his co-workers in an on-campus work environment as a female to male transgender individual. While this was difficult, he was met with support, care, and open minds. His friends have been tremendously supportive as well. Chris also has a support network on- and off-campus, which is crucial given what the next few months are going to look like for him.
While this may not be a typical experience on college campuses for a student dealing with identity issues, I am proud to say it is not the first positive story I've encountered over the past five years. In March 2005, Central Washington University added gender identity and gender expression to its non-discrimination policy in an effort to be inclusive of all our students. At the time, it was the twenty-third college in the nation to do so (according to transgenderlaw.org), and dozens of institutions across the nation have since done likewise.
However, supporting the transgender population goes above and beyond policy—although that is an important first step. What are we doing to support this emerging population? How do we create inclusive campus environments that model acceptance and, at the very least, tolerance? What does that mean exactly—an inclusive student, faculty, and staff non-discrimination policy? Support services available through health and counseling centers? Advocacy programs like Safe Spaces or Bias Response Plans? Co-curricular educational programming that mirrors the populations we serve? I'd answer yes to all the above, and more. Several universities that have created living and learning communities specific to gay, lesbian, bisexual, and transgender students have implemented "transgender-friendly" training programs for faculty and staff, have created gender-neutral restrooms, or have added gender identity and expression to their anti-harassment policies (www.lgbtcampus.org).
Definitions may be useful. According to the Human Rights Campaign, the largest GLBT advocacy group in the US, "transgender" is "an overarching term that includes those expressing gender characteristics that don't correspond with characteristics traditionally ascribed to the person's sex or presumed sex." Many times, the terms "transgender" and "transsexual" are confused or combined, but they are separate concepts. While being transsexual does not necessarily denote a desire to alter one's physical self through hormone therapy and surgery, the term is often used to mean so, even by those in the transgender community. Gender variance, from transgender to transsexuality, is distinct from sexual orientation in that it is not about sexual expression but gender expression; in other words, it is about presenting a gender identity, a feeling of being feminine or masculine, rather than an expression of sexuality.
What we need to recognize and understand is that definitions are fluid. When it all boils down to it, our students do not want to be put in boxes by us. Many students want to self-identify and sometimes that identification changes throughout a given period of time. I've learned over the years that rather than attempting to find meaning, empathy or understanding in a definition or a box, getting to know the student as they are, as they identify, and as they grow and change is important.
I talked with Chris about writing this article and sharing his nervousness about approaching his mother that weekend. He wanted to share with you an anecdote about how the conversation went. . . .
Sound off!
Sound off! Gay
Friday, October 05, 2007
Don’t leave trans people behind in ENDA push
Re: “ENDA hits a snag over trans inclusion” (news, Sept. 28)
Rep. Barney Frank’s action to carve gender identity from ENDA may be politically expedient, but the result will not offer protection to gays or lesbians, either. The absence of gender identity in ENDA means that I, as an employer, may fire a gay person for being effeminate or a lesbian for being overly butch. Transgender people need ENDA more than any other identity group. It is common to find transgender people with doctorates and master’s degrees working for minimum wage. Frank’s claim that not enough education has been done is a canard. Transgender people have been lobbying the Hill since 1995 for inclusion in ENDA.
Barney Frank is really Barney Fife. When is Andy going to come to the rescue and save Barney from shooting himself in the foot? Rep. Frank, Speaker Nancy Pelosi, and HRC’s Joe Solmonese are way out of line if they believe that they have the duty or the right to split up our community.
As a united community, we can better demand our basic human rights. If we are willing to exclude others, we are as guilty as the bigots entrenched in mainstream society. Divided we will fall. Does that sound familiar to anyone?
Leaving transgender individuals out of ENDA is placing our most vulnerable “queer” segment at greater risk. Thank you, HRC, for maintaining your principles and refusing to accept such an ineffective bill.
I think that those in the “community” who drop trans people like me at the first opportunity should expect no help, money, votes or sympathy. What are you thinking? To paraphrase Abe Lincoln, a house divided cannot stand.
If ENDA can only pass without a transgender provision at this time, then our community should still support the measure and not abandon it! We’ve had to wait much too long as it is to get this chance to have ENDA come up for a vote at all. If we fail to support the measure now, then 2009 is a long way off and we have less certainty that the Congress or White House will back ENDA then. Transgender people should not be selfish and expect us to kill the bill simply because it cannot be passed with them now. Let ENDA become law first and we can all then fight to pass a standalone transgender bill in the future.
Bryn Mawr Now
Filmmaker-Historian Susan Stryker to Screen
Film on Key Moment in Transgender History
Susan Stryker, a historian, filmmaker and theorist whose work has been influential in determining the direction of the emerging field of transgender studies, will visit Bryn Mawr next week.
After meeting with students in two seminars in the College's program in gender and sexuality studies, Stryker will present and discuss her award-winning documentary, Screaming Queens: The Riot at Compton's Cafeteria on Thursday, Oct. 11, at 4:30 p.m. in Carpenter B21.
Screaming Queens tells the story of a little-known uprising by transgender people in San Francisco's Tenderloin district in 1966, three years before the famous Stonewall incident in New York.
The Tenderloin was a red-light district and a ghetto for gender rebels who were subject to regular harassment by police. In the summer of 1966, a budding transgender-rights movement focused on the neighborhood tensions that burst out at Compton's Cafeteria one August night.
The cafeteria was populated by its usual clientele of drag performers and street hustlers when the management summoned police to subdue a noisy crowd at one table. But on this occasion, a drag queen surprised police and onlookers by throwing her coffee in an officer's face.
The melee that ensued, Stryker says, was a pivotal moment in the history of transgender activism.
The film examines the incident through the first-person narratives of people who were present: drag performers, prostitutes and police officers.
It also presents the story of Stryker's rediscovery of the hitherto unrecorded uprising and the research that allowed her to document it.
Placing the riot and the transgender-rights movement that grew out of it in the context of other social-justice movements of the period, Screaming Queens notes the "dramatic changes in medical practices, urban politics, neighborhood geography and public consciousness" that followed it.
Stryker herself is an important figure in transgender activism. After earning a Ph.D. in history from the University of California at Berkeley in 1992, she created a performance piece that grew out of her work with Transgender nation, a direct-action advocacy group. A text adaptation of the piece, titled "My Words To Victor Frankenstein Above the Village of Chamounix — Performing Transgender Rage," appeared in GLQ: A Journal of Lesbian and Gay Studies in 1994 and quickly became a staple of gender-and-sexuality-studies reading lists.
Since then, the prolific Stryker has produced a number of important works. In 1998, she edited the "Transgender Issue" of The Journal of Lesbian and Gay Studies, a watershed in transgender studies. Among the books she has published are Gay By the Bay: A History of Queer Culture in the San Francisco Bay Area, Queer Pulp: Perverted Passions From the Golden Age of the Paperback, and The Transgender Studies Reader. She was featured in Monika Treut's film Gendernauts and was scenarist and scriptwriter for Brandon, Shu Lea Cheang's online multimedia installation examining gender, embodiment, violence and media at the SoHo Guggenheim.
TV Landscape Changing for Transgender Characters
October 4, 2007
The portrayal of transgender characters on television these days seems to be sort of a glass-is-either-half-empty-or-half-full situation. For years television has presented a steady stream of “transsexual” prostitutes, murder victims, and other assorted minor characters that usually appeared for one episode and were portrayed as little more than a collection of stereotypes to advance the plot or get a cheap laugh.
A recent example of that aired this past summer on HBO’s hit show Entourage. In the episode “Sorry, Harvey” a secondary storyline centered on Johnny Drama (Kevin Dillon) trying to get the sad sack mayor of Beverly Hills (played by Groundhog Day’s Stephen Tobolowsky) hooked up with a beautiful woman in order to curry his favor. At a bar to which he takes the mayor, Drama thinks he has succeeded with a woman named Anika — at least until he learns that she is actually transgender.
The mayor turns out not to mind, but the show portrays this as due more to his being so pathetic rather than a message of acceptance. This impression is further underscored by the main characters’ clearly being repulsed at the idea of a transgender person, and by the episode’s big “reveal” when Anika’s male genitalia are shown during a panty-less Britney Spear’s-type incident.
On the “half-full” side of the equation there is ABC’s Ugly Betty. Last season the hit dramedy included Alexis Meade, a transgender character portrayed as self-accepting, not desperate for the approval of a man, and who wasn’t a prostitute. Audiences loved the character.
Already the most diverse network when it comes to LGBT representation, ABC deepened their diversity with two new transgender characters introduced this fall, one each on Dirty Sexy Money and Big Shots. Neither are regulars at this point, and while the Dirty Sexy Money show continues to build on the progress of Ugly Betty, thus far Big Shots is a throwback to more stereotypical portrayals of transgender women. (There are no transgender men – female to male – characters currently on network TV.)
Despite setbacks like the recent episode of Entourage, Mara Keisling, Executive Director for the National Center for Transgender Equality, believes things are improving when it comes to transgender representations on television. “I’m really, really optimistic. Things are changing so much so fast. Oprah has had so many sensitive shows. Montel has done some good shows. Larry King does show after show, and that’s just really educating the public.”
As to what is driving that change, Keisling stated, “It’s just natural that as there are more and more trans people visible in public, that’s going to be reflected in popular culture.”
That includes Dirty Sexy Money’s Carmelita (Candis Cayne), a transgender woman having an affair with Patrick Darling (William Baldwin), a wealthy man soon to be a U.S. senator. Though their affair is illicit, Darling does seem to love Carmelita and they are even shown in bed together after having made love. The fact she is transgender is not treated as a punch line or “revealed” as something disgusting or shocking.
And Then There Were None
Though Donna Rose resigned as the first and only transgender member of the Human Rights Campaign’s Board of Directors on Wednesday, she has no hard feelings toward the organization.
“I really believe that the board feels as though they have the best interest of the LGBT community in mind even though the end result doesn’t appear that way,” she told The Advocate, adding that work she has done with HRC has provided some of her “proudest” moments.
But on Monday, HRC’s Board met for four “very emotional” hours, according to Rose, and issued a statement saying it would not advocate for passage of an Employment Nondiscrimination Act that lacked protections for both sexual orientation and gender identity. The original, trans-inclusive ENDA was split into two separate bills last week by Rep. Barney Frank, an out member of the House of Representatives, because he feared the inclusive bill lacked the votes for passage.
The HRC board’s statement posted Monday read, “HRC will not support the newly introduced sexual orientation only bill.” But the real controversy erupted around what wasn’t said -- HRC’s statement never indicated that it would oppose passing the “sexual orientation” only bill.
“I could not fulfill my obligations as a board member to support that tepid stance,” said Rose.
Most insiders believe the creation of two bills will lead to passing the non-inclusive ENDA through both chambers of Congress perhaps this year (though President Bush may very well veto it), while leaving the “gender identity” bill to languish for an untold number of years. A non-inclusive ENDA was passed in New York, for instance, in 2002, while five years later, its gender counterpart (GENDA) still has an uncertain future. . . .
Thursday, October 04, 2007
One Life: Two Genders
Kaylah Baca
10/4/07Jennifer Boylan read exerpts from her two acclaimed books "I'm Looking Through You" and "She's Not There" to a full room yesterday. The later, "She's Not There," is the first best-selling book by a transgender.
"It is impossible to hate anyone whose story you know," said Boylan, an English Professor at Colby College who visited the Rainbow Center Wednesday Afternoon.
After being introduced by the new director of the Rainbow Center, Fleurette King, Boylan began telling the crowd about a piece of legislation that is struggling to be passed. The new law would forbid employers from firing someone on the basis of sexual orientation or gender identity. Before it was up for vote, it was thought that perhaps the bill would have a higher chance of passing if the gender identity section was taken out. When human rights activists heard about this, they were outraged. Boylan went on to say that the law is somewhat at a standstill,and will probably be vetoed by President Bush and is a perfect example of what the majority of America still thinks about transgender people or trans-identity as a whole.
Before Boylan began to read from her book "She's Not There," she gave a little background information on herself and her family. She is of Irish decent and as she read aloud excerpts of dialogue between herself and her father, she even took on a perfect Irish accent. Boylan grew up in a large house in the suburbs of Philadelphia with her parents and sister. The house, she said, was haunted, in "more than just the Scooby-Doo type of way."
She described hearing voices and cold spots in the house, otherwise known as haunted. The other ghosts she described as a part of her past.
Boylan began by reading the chapter about a time she stayed with her grandmother, whom she called Gammie, and her friend, while her parents were away watching her sister ride horses. At the time she was actually a male and only 12 years old. During that time period in her life, she was seriously trying to figure out what to do with the bad feelings about herself and the body she woke up in every morning. Boylan told the audience that she took the "Big Walk" while she stayed with her Gammie. The chapter described how she sat upon a rock next to the ocean and pondered her thoughts of feeling not quite like a boy, yet knowing she was not a boy. She questioned, how can I be something that is impossible for me to be? After watching the waves crash against the rocks for some time, she thought, "Maybe I can be cured by love, then perhaps I would still be content to be a boy." . . .
New York Post: MIRIAM DUCKS 'MIRIAM' BOW
Washington Post: Letters To The Editor
'The Justness of Our Cause'
Thursday, October 4, 2007; Page A24
The Employment Non-Discrimination Act would send a strong message concerning discrimination against gays. The Sept. 28 editorial, "A Civil Rights Law," sent one as well: To gain our inalienable human rights, transgender people must first convince the public that we are human.
The Post's proposed solution, that transgender people embark on 40 years of educating the public, is naive at best and cynical at worst. We are so small in number and so easily ignored at negligible political cost. Every group that has fought for its civil rights has been a minority dependent on people outside the group to recognize the justness of its cause. Those who claim to believe in justice must recognize that you either believe in an egalitarian society open to all or in one where discrimination is a valid societal response, only requiring you to pick your targets carefully.
POV, Critique, Opinion: Dr. Discrimination
Montgomery Co. Council hears testimony on transgender bill
by Yusef Najafi
October 4, 2007
While presenting her testimony to the Montgomery County Council Tuesday, Oct. 2, against the passage of a bill that would protect transgender people by adding the words ''gender identity'' to the county's anti-discrimination policy, Dr. Ruth Jacobs, an infectious disease and allergy specialist, wore a white lab coat -- completing the look with a stethoscope around her neck. Looking like she had just walked off the set of Grey's Anatomy, Jacobs, the only person to offer testimony against the bill at the public hearing, warned that passage of Bill No. 23-07, sponsored by Councilmember Duchy Trachtenberg (D-At Large), would discriminate against ''ex-transgenders.'' These are, she claims, people who have ''stepped out of'' being transgender.
Bandying the technical term ''gender identity disorder,'' a controversial diagnosis generally required in the United States before gender reassignment surgery may be performed, Jacobs asked the Council to ''be true to biology.''
Trachtenberg, who holds a master's degree in social work and once maintained a private practice in adolescent addiction, said she found Jacobs' testimony biased and lacking in merit because of Jacobs' lack of experience and training in dealing with the transgender community.
''As someone who is trained clinically to work with people in the area of mental health, what I would suggest to you is that there...are rare instances of where transgender status is identified as mental illness,'' Trachtenberg countered. ''Even if it was the case,...it would still be wrong to discriminate against an individual based on a medical condition.''
Maryanne Arnow, a professional chef who has lived in Montgomery County for the past 37 years, testified that, as a male-to-female transgender woman, she has found it difficult to find employment.
''This is very painful and difficult, especially in light of my talents and my desire to share those talents with others,'' she said.
Carrie Evans, policy director at Equality Maryland, said passage of the bill would protect people such as Arnow against discrimination in employment, housing and other public accommodations.
''In this measure, gender identity is defined as an individual's actual or perceived gender, including a person's physical appearance, expression, image, identity or behavior,'' she said. ''Whether or not those characteristics differ from the characteristics customarily associated with a person's assigned sex at birth.''
Lois Hackey, compliance program manager for Montgomery County's Office of Human Rights, spoke on behalf of Montgomery County Executive Isiah Leggett, who also supports the bill.
Dan Furmansky, executive director of Equality Maryland, said by passing such legislation, Montgomery County would join ''a growing national trend'' currently visible in 13 states and 90 local jurisdictions across the United States.
''Discrimination is happening in Montgomery County, as much as we'd like to pride ourselves in having a progressive jurisdiction,'' Furmansky told the Council. ''I hope we can all be able to agree that people should be able to live their lives free from discrimination and should be judged on the basis of their ability to do a job.''
The Council's Health and Human Services Committee is scheduled to take up the bill at its Oct. 15 meeting.
Wednesday, October 03, 2007
TG in Cody, Wyoming
"On March 2, 2007 I spoke at the 6th annual Wells College activist symposium: Engage Conflict. I presented "The Life of a Transgender." Here is the first part of my speech."
Transgenders do need protection laws
"We don't serve your kind here, get out."
"I don't rent to people like you."
"Don't even bother applying, your type isn't welcome here."
What would you do if you heard these words. Call a lawyer? Call the newspaper? Fight back? Not if you happen to be transgender, like me, because in many places that type of discrimination is completely legal. Really.
If you should see me on the street you probably wouldn't notice me. I'm a plain, soft spoken young man. But as a transgender person I carry the constant fear that I'll face harassment or discrimination, and that I have no legal recourse when prejudice comes my way. I have lost job opportunities, been turned away from renting an apartment and even been denied medical care because I am transgender.
In 2005, I had a medical emergency. The EMTs would not touch me. I was told if I wanted to ride in the ambulance, I had to strap myself into the gurney. They refused to take my vitals and called me a "freak."
I grew up in Broward County and graduated from Coral Springs High School. I'm proud of my home town because we are a community known for leadership in valuing all people. Yet our county's Human Rights Ordinance does not include four words — "gender identity" and "gender expression" — that would grant transgender citizens the basic human rights every resident deserves.
A recent editorial in the South Florida Sun Sentinel made the mistaken claim that as a transgender person, I'm already protected by our county's human rights ordinance, but that is simply not true. Here are the facts. A transgender person can be fired, denied service in restaurants and other places of public accommodation, prevented from renting or purchasing property, discriminated against and harassed in virtually every other aspect of our lives in Broward County and it's perfectly legal.
Hopefully that won't be the case for long. All over the country, cities, counties and states are deciding to protect transgender people from discrimination in employment, public accommodations and housing. And Florida is part of this trend. . . .
ENDA Breakthrough
Yesterday, something happened that apparently never happens: the Speaker of the U.S. House of Representatives reversed herself. On the issue of transgender inclusion in the Employment Non-Discrimination Act (ENDA), Speaker Nancy Pelosi (D-Calif.) and U.S. Reps. George Miller (chair of the House Education and Labor Committee), Barney Frank (D-Mass.), and Tammy Baldwin (D.-Wis.) issued the following statement at 5:43 p.m. on Monday:
“After discussions with congressional leaders and organizations supporting passage of ENDA, we have agreed to schedule mark-up of the bill in the Committee on Education and Labor later this month, followed by a vote in the full House. This schedule will allow proponents of the legislation to continue their discussions with Members in the interest of passing the broadest possible bill.”
Only three days earlier, Pelosi had issued a statement supporting the bill being proposed by U.S. Rep. Barney Frank (D-Mass.) that would have removed gender identity and expression from the legislation, leaving transgendered and gender-variant people still without protection from discrimination under federal law:
“…While I personally favor legislation that would include gender identity, the new ENDA legislation proposed by Congressman Frank has the best prospects for success on the House floor…”
The Sept. 28 statement from the Speaker’s office touched off a firestorm of protest from a host of national LGBT organizations and virtually every statewide organization, who strongly opposed the effort to strip gender identity and expression from the ENDA bill. The Speaker’s decision to delay the committee mark-up of the ‘trans-free’ ENDA bill, came about after several days of frenzied activity on the part of several organizations, including the National Center for Transgender Equality, the National Gay & Lesbian Task Force, the National Stonewall Democrats, the National Center for Lesbian Rights, the Equality Federation, and Pride At Work, among others.
In the interests of full disclosure, I should mention that the New York Association for Gender Rights Advocacy is a member of the Equality Federation and that, as chair, I represent NYAGRA in the Federation. I’m also a member of Pride At Work, though I did not take part in the PAW organizing around this issue. PAW and the Transgender Law Center organized a vigil outside Nancy Pelosi’s district office in San Francisco, which apparently played a significant role in the Speaker’s decision on Monday to reverse herself.Two letters to the Speaker’s office played a crucial role in the decision. One letter from the Task Force, calling on the House leadership to scrap the non-inclusive ENDA bill, was co-signed by more than 90 national, state and local organizations, from Parents, Families and Friends of Lesbians and Gays (P-FLAG) to BiNet USA to Equality Texas Center to Center Advocates of Milwaukee. The other, a letter from the Leadership Conference on Civil Rights, the coalition leading the campaign for the federal hate crimes bill, called on the House Education and Labor Committee Chairman George Miller to cancel the mark-up scheduled for today (Tuesday). The LCCR letter was signed by 20 of its member organizations, including the American Civil Liberties Union, Legal Momentum, People For the American Way, the Unitarian Universalist Association of Congregations and — crucially — the Human Rights Campaign, the largest, wealthiest, and most influential LGBT rights organization in the country. . . .
Australia: ABRAMS WINS PASSPORT CASE
| Fiona Power and Grace Abrams | |
Grace Abrams and Fiona Power have become the first legally recognised same-sex couple in Australia.
The Federal Government was last week forced to formally acknowledge the marriage, following a decision by the Administrative Appeals Tribunal to grant a female passport to Abrams, a post-operative trans woman.
Abrams had married her long-term female partner using her male birth certificate before undergoing gender reassignment surgery in Thailand in 2005.
On her return to Australia, she was denied a passport in her new gender on the basis that she was married to a woman.
She appealed this decision by Foreign Affairs Minister Alexander Downer in the tribunal in Sydney last month.
Abrams maintained that without a female passport she was unable to travel, contradicting both the Australian Passports Act, which states that every Australian citizen is entitled to a passport, and the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights, which states that everyone has the right to liberty of movement and freedom to choose their residence.
This position was ultimately accepted by tribunal Deputy President, The Hon RNJ Purvis AM, QC, who instructed the Minister to issue an Australian passport to Abrams, noting her female gender.
Abrams has advised others in the same circumstance to apply for their passports now, while the decision still stands.
“There are a lot of couples in this situation who have to choose between having their gender recognised or their family,” she said.
“And that is why we went through this, to assert that this is an unfair situation and actually illegal to deny an Australian citizen a passport.
“We are the first officially, begrudgingly recognised same-sex couple and now we have to try to leverage it to force a change in the law that recognises other same-sex couples.”
Abrams’ lawyer David Shoebridge said the tribunal’s decision was a victory for common sense in the law over prejudice.
“Other transgendered people, whether they’re married or not, should now be able to get a passport without being monstered by incredulous policy positions within the department,” he said.
Greens Senator Kerry Nettle said the case set an important precedent for other transgender people.
“We know the Government is trying to make things more difficult for transgender people trying to get passports,” she said.
The Senator acknowledged that Abrams and Power now had a legally recognised same-sex marriage.
“And that is probably why the Government was fighting so hard in this court case, because they didn’t want that precedent to be set.”
Poll: Should the Government now offer same-sex marriage? Vote at www.ssonet.com.au.
sfgate: Readers' Platform: Transgender rights and wrongs
Here is a sample of the more than 230 comments - reflecting a vigorous debate in the gay, lesbian and transgender communities - registered on SFGate by 6 p.m. Tuesday. To see all the comments, go to sfgate.com/ZBAG.
I think this is the saddest day I have seen in my 30 years as an out of the closet gay man. Today could have been momentous. The US Congress would have finally passed a major non-discrimination bill. Instead our so-called "leaders" allowed the process to be hijacked by the most extreme elements in our community and as a result NOTHING will be passed. The behavior of GLAAD, FLAG, etc., is like spoiled children throwing a tantrum because they didn't get everything they want for Christmas. And now we find out that HRC has also capitulated to the demands of the extremists. When there is NO gay rights bill remember who to thank.
- James Short, 44, Chico
I am a transsexual woman. To all the gay and lesbian groups who stood up and made the LGBT mean something, thank you. I love you all. I totally do. To those gays who do not understand why we are included, no we are not all hetero; roughly half of us are lesbian. Straight people generally think that all gay drag queens are transsexual, by the way, and I get called "homosexual" all the time. So yeah, it's confusing. We are a small community but many of you are a part of us; does that make sense?
- Darlie Brewster, 49, Sherman Oaks
Actually many of us identify as gay. For instance, I am a lesbian. If the TG-excluding legislation goes forward (without condemnation from the [Human Rights Campaign] , two important, devastatingly bad messages would be sent: (1) Not even the TG community's closest allies support them, so it must be OK to discriminate ("Hell, let's stomp and kill a few of 'em, too!"); (2) The HRC cannot be trusted to keep a promise it has been making for over three years, that it would never accept transgender exclusion from ENDA [Employment Non-Discrimination Act].
- Christine Beatty, 49, Los Angeles
It seems to me that 'biting the hand that feeds' at this juncture is a self-defeating exercise. I wonder to whom the gay organizers spoke prior to making this submission to our congressional representatives? I certainly hope it wasn't a unilateral decision made without the input of the greater community.
- Howard Binstock, 65, Vacaville
I am not willing to tell transgendered classmates of mine that their sexual identity rights are less important than those of the gays and lesbians and that they should wait their turn. Are you?
- Brittany Gary, 25, Oakland
I would rather see an advance on one front than seeing nothing at all being done. An anti-transgender discrimination bill can be added in a more enlightened time when Congress is less infested with conservatives.
- Bob Hughes, 57, San Francisco
Of course, all of this debate is moot. If something magical happens and the bill makes it out of both House and Senate, the president will veto it regardless of the inclusion of transgendered people. Since the bill is going to die, why not take advantage of the situation and stand together and say "We want discrimination to end for everyone!"
- Jennifer Larkin, 35, San Francisco
Prohibiting job discrimination should be enacted to protect those who work or are applying to work. Period. If a person is fired or not hired for reasons other than their ability to perform the tasks the job demands (ie. black, transgendered, toothless, Catholic - you get the picture), they ought to have recourse.
- Clinton Fein, 42, San Francisco
Baby steps may be frustrating and humiliating for some, but baby steps are progress.
- Jared Angel, 35, Kobe, Japan
In order to make real change we, as the LGBT community need a show of force. March on Washington, anyone?
- Jon Phillips, 43, New York City
Tuesday, October 02, 2007
Ireland: Death threat terror of sex change couple

By Stephen Breen
Evil drug-dealers were last night slammed for threatening to kill Ulster's own real life Roy and Hayley - Robbie McCullough and his sex-change partner Stephanie.
Speaking to Sunday Life from their under-siege Co Down home, Stephanie claims they have been subjected to a campaign of terror in recent months.
The 38-year-old transsexual woman and her 58-year-old husband have pleaded with the thugs to leave them alone.
The couple - married by controversial priest Pat Buckley in 2000 - also told how:
- They have been warned by cops they are under "severe" threat;
- Thugs have threatened to burn their house down;
- Stephanie has been branded "he-she" in the street;
- Drug-dealers promised to batter Robbie with a baseball bat and;
- Vicious rumours have been directed against them.
Stephanie - who is on anti-depressants because of the abuse - remains a prisoner in her own home.
She said: "The only time I can leave the house is when I have my Rottweiler Tini beside me.
"She is a great dog and also fantastic with kids, but she would rip anyone apart if they attacked me.
"I know I have been abused in the past by ignorant people, but this is more sinister now because the police have told us we are facing a serious threat.
"Robbie has also been told that we are going to be burnt out and we should not have to live like this."
Added Stephanie: "We are sleeping in the living room because we have to be very vigilant and watch to see if anyone is coming up the street.
"When I have been out of the house they have been calling me 'he-she', yet they don't know anything about me.
"I have a birth certificate to prove I am a woman and if these thugs want to see it, they can.
"They are telling lies about us and making up nasty rumours, but we just ignore them. Everyone knows we cause no trouble to anyone."
The couple, who have vowed to remain in Co Down, met in 1997, three years after Stephanie first started the process to become a woman. . . .
Babette Francis: A gender bender of a fishy tale
Babette Francis
October 02, 2007 12:00am
THE view that humans come in two kinds, male and female, is under challenge if not outdated.
In a rear-guard action, the Fatherhood Foundation launched a booklet, 21 Reasons Why Gender Matters.
Several politicians, including Prime Minister John Howard, dropped in to the launch and more or less agreed humans consist of men and women, and marriage should be between a man and a woman.
However, they are all swimming against the tide. Sex changes are everywhere. Grace Abrams was born a male but has changed to female and complains she can't get an Australian passport as a female because he was married as a male.
Then 60 Minutes showed a boy who decided, as a two-year-old, that he was really a girl and dressed accordingly. He is now going to have hormones and surgery.
But the real insight into gender assignation comes from male fish in British rivers. About one-third of the male fish are developing female characteristics in a trend that could change the ecological balance of the waterways.
Concerned environmentalists are calling for a ban on pesticides, but the problem is not pesticides but estrogens from birth control pills.
Estrogens cannot be removed by existing methods of sewage treatment and, of course, we can't do without the Pill.
Lest anyone think British fish are just being eccentric as the British are apt to be (boys will be boys, or in this case, boys will be girls) the situation is the same in Washington DC.
Washington is separated from British rivers by a substantial pool, the Atlantic Ocean. But scientists have found certain species of male fish in the Potomac River are showing female traits. They are developing eggs in their testes.
Fish pathologist Vicki Blazer says the trend may be caused by chemicals -- read estrogen -- in the Potomac.
Professor Charles Tyler of Exeter University is worried. "The soup of estrogen is responsible for causing these changes to the fish. It is abnormal. These fish should be male or female," says the professor.
"The fact that we have such a large proportion across the country is not right." . . .
Fox Reality Channel to Air the US Premiere of Controversial UK Reality Show, ``There’s Something About Miriam''
LOS ANGELES--(BUSINESS WIRE)--“There’s Something About Miriam” and that something has everyone talking! Fox Reality Channel, the only all-reality, all-the-time television network, will debut the controversial hit series on October 31 as a special sneak preview. The show’s regular time slot will be late night Sundays at 1:00 AM ET/10:00PM PT beginning November 4, concluding on December 9. “There’s Something About Miriam” first premiered in the UK in February 2004 and quickly became one of the most widely discussed and controversial reality shows ever aired due to its dramatic conclusion.
Hosted by Tim Vincent (“Access Hollywood”), “There’s Something About Miriam” chronicles the journey of six men who travel to a luxurious house in Ibiza, Spain, and enter into a heated dating competition to win the heart of a stunning 21-year old Mexican model, Miriam. But Miriam’s secret, that she was born a man, is not revealed to the contestants until the final episode.
The six contestants include: optician Mark Dimino, student Toby Green, chef Aron Lane, lifeguard and ex-ski instructor Tom Rooke, martial arts expert Scott Gibson and Royal Marine, Dominic Conway. The men engage in various dating “competitions” to win Miriam’s heart, including a swimming race, rock climbing, a chariot race and poetry writing. The final prize included 10,000 pounds, one week on a luxury yacht, and hopefully, Miriam’s heart. All are captivated by her outward and inward beauty and most do not suspect that she is a transgender woman.
“Fox Reality Channel is dedicated to bringing its audience the most talked about, edgy reality shows from around the globe,” said David Lyle, President, Fox Reality Channel. “We are at the forefront of airing programs that create and stir up dialogue.”
Miriam was born in Mexico in 1982 and realized early on that she wanted to be a girl. With the support of her family, she began her transition process at the age of 12. After launching a modeling career she decided that she would take a chance and star in the reality dating show, originally entitled “Find Me a Man.” Miriam explained to TV Plus, “I did it because I wanted to know if real love exists.” After the finale of “There’s Something about Miriam” in the UK, Miriam went on to become a guest visitor on “Big Brother Australia.” . . .